Compare and contrast the poem ‘On Killing a Tree’ by Gieve Patel (Beehive – Textbook in English for Class IX, NCERT) with the poem The Trees by ADRIENNE RICH.
Model Answer & Options
Source: TextbookBoth On Killing a Tree by Gieve Patel and The Trees by Adrienne Rich focus on the relationship between humans and nature. However, their perspectives differ. Patel’s poem describes the brutal destruction of a tree, emphasizing nature’s resilience against human interference. In contrast, Rich’s poem depicts trees breaking free from confinement, symbolizing the struggle for freedom.
The tone of On Killing a Tree is harsh and realistic, highlighting violence, whereas The Trees is symbolic and hopeful, suggesting liberation. Patel portrays trees as victims of human cruelty, while Rich presents them as symbols of rebellion.
Both poems use trees as metaphors—Patel’s tree represents nature’s endurance, while Rich’s trees symbolize human struggle for freedom. Together, they emphasize the conflict between human actions and nature but offer contrasting views—one of destruction and the other of hope.
Try a Related Quiz
Test your skills on a similar concept: Master the NCERT Glimpses of India Chapter with Our Practice Quiz.
Related Questions
- →
Find, in the first stanza, three things that cannot happen in a treeless forest.
- →
What picture do these words create in your mind: “… sun bury its feet in shadow…”? What could the poet mean by the sun’s ‘feet’?
- →
Where are the trees in the poem? What do their roots, their leaves, and their twigs do?
- →
What does the poet compare their branches to?
- →
How does the poet describe the moon: (a) at the beginning of the third stanza, and (b) at its end? What causes this change?